Justice Varma tells Lok Sabha his resignation ends removal proceedings; Speaker yet to decide next step
In a letter now circulated to MPs, the former Allahabad High Court judge says Parliament cannot go on with his removal. An inquiry committee had found the charges against him proved; he denies them.

Justice Yashwant Varma has told the Lok Sabha that proceedings to remove him as a High Court judge cannot continue because he has already resigned, according to a letter that was circulated to MPs on Thursday, PTI reported.
In the letter, dated 10 September and addressed to Lok Sabha Secretary General Utpal Kumar Singh, Varma wrote: "Upon my resignation, proceedings directed towards my removal from office did not survive and cannot be continued." He said any attempt to remove him would have no constitutional basis, according to PTI.
Varma said he is innocent of the allegations against him, including the suggestion that he held ill-gotten money, and asked that his resignation not be treated as an admission of any allegation or finding, PTI reported. He cited Article 217(1)(a) of the Constitution and a 1978 Supreme Court Constitution Bench ruling, Union of India vs Gopal Chandra Misra, to argue that a High Court judge's resignation does not need anyone's acceptance. He asked that the letter be placed before both Houses and the matter closed, and said he reserved the right to challenge the inquiry's findings.
The case goes back to 14 March 2025, when a fire at his official residence in Delhi, where he was then a Delhi High Court judge, led to the discovery of burnt currency notes. A Supreme Court in-house committee then examined the matter, and the then Chief Justice of India, Sanjiv Khanna, recommended his removal, according to PTI. Varma was moved to the Allahabad High Court.
In August 2025, Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla admitted a removal notice signed by MPs from both the ruling and opposition sides and set up a three-member committee under the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968, headed by Supreme Court judge Justice Aravind Kumar. The Supreme Court dismissed Varma's challenge to the committee.
Varma resigned on 9 April 2026 and withdrew from the inquiry, maintaining his innocence, the Supreme Court Observer reported. The committee continued without him and submitted its report to the Speaker on 18 May. The report, tabled in Parliament on 12 August, found all three charges proved: failing to explain the cash, failing to secure evidence, and giving explanations it described as evasive, PTI reported.
What happens next is not yet settled. On 4 November, Birla said: "We will examine the rules and consult leaders of political parties before deciding on the future course of action," according to PTI, as carried by National Herald. That report said the Law Ministry had not yet notified acceptance of the resignation. No response from the Lok Sabha Secretariat or the government to Varma's letter had been reported by Friday.
The Supreme Court Observer has noted that the 1968 law does not settle whether post-retirement benefits can be forfeited when misbehaviour is found proved against a judge who has already left office.
Get the day's best stories on WhatsApp. Free, a few a day, no spam.
Follow on WhatsAppSource ledger · स्रोत खाता
Each fact in this story, where it came from, and how it was checked.
| Fact | Source | Check |
|---|---|---|
| Letter dated 10 Sept to LS SG Utpal Kumar Singh; circulated to MPs Thursday; 'did not survive and cannot be continued'; no constitutional foundation; innocence incl. ill-gotten funds; resignation not admission; report tabled 12 Aug found three charges proved | The Tribune/PTI | Confirmed, independent outlets |
| Letter dated 10 Sept to LS SG Utpal Kumar Singh; circulated to MPs Thursday; 'did not survive and cannot be continued'; no constitutional foundation; innocence incl. ill-gotten funds; resignation not admission; report tabled 12 Aug found three charges proved | Scroll/PTI | Confirmed, independent outlets |
| Letter dated 10 Sept to LS SG Utpal Kumar Singh; circulated to MPs Thursday; 'did not survive and cannot be continued'; no constitutional foundation; innocence incl. ill-gotten funds; resignation not admission; report tabled 12 Aug found three charges proved | Siasat/PTI | Confirmed, independent outlets |
| Exact quote 'Upon my resignation...'; Article 217(1)(a); Gopal Chandra Misra 1978; asks letter be placed before both Houses; reserves right to challenge; 9 April resignation; CJI Khanna recommended removal; resignation not yet notified | Siasat/PTI (20 Nov) | Single source |
| 14 March 2025 fire; Aravind Kumar committee; SC dismissed challenge to committee | Scroll/PTI | Confirmed, independent outlets |
| 14 March 2025 fire; Aravind Kumar committee; SC dismissed challenge to committee | Business Today | Confirmed, independent outlets |
| Resigned 9 April 2026, withdrew from inquiry; committee continued ex parte; report to Speaker 18 May; 1968 Act does not answer whether post-retirement benefits can be forfeited | Supreme Court Observer (19 May) | Single source |
| Birla 4 Nov quote; multi-party notice admitted Aug 2025; Law Ministry yet to notify acceptance | National Herald/PTI (4 Nov) | Single source |
Corrections to this story: none.