Checked, then printedEach story lists its facts, their sources and how they were verified.
NewsKhata
न्यूज़खाता

Every story shows its sources.

← Front page

Beauty

MP bans two 'Made in Pakistan' whitening creams, but Indore traders say theirs comes from Haryana

Madhya Pradesh's drug regulator has banned Goree Beauty Cream and Chandni Whitening Cream over heavy metals. Raids in Indore seized over 300 packets, and lab tests will now decide what the cream really is.

Plain black cosmetic bottles
Unbranded cosmetic bottles (representative image; not the seized products). Photo: Plasticbottlesupplier / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

If you bought a cheap fairness cream from a neighbourhood cosmetics counter, check the label tonight. On 14 November, Madhya Pradesh's Food and Drug Administration banned the sale, purchase and use of two skin whitening creams it says were made in Pakistan, Gori (also spelt Goree) Beauty Cream and Chandni Whitening Cream. It warned that heavy metals in them could cause toxic effects and may damage the kidneys, the Free Press Journal reported.

The state order comes on top of a national alert. In mid-September, ANI reported, the Central Drugs Standard Control Organisation (CDSCO), India's drug and cosmetics regulator, put out a public health alert on the same two products. It said tests had found heavy metals above the permitted limits and that neither cream held the import registration certificate a foreign cosmetic needs before it can be sold in India.

Officials then went looking for stock in Indore. The Free Press Journal said raids on 13 November covered two places: a cosmetics shop in Ranipura and Padmashree Agency, a distributor in Chhawani. Around 300 packets worth about ₹1.5 lakh were seized at the distributor. Dainik Jagran's English site counted 315 pieces at the agency. It said a three-member team led by drug inspector Varun Kumar Rai took three pieces under seal from the shop.

Here's the twist. The traders say the product isn't Pakistani at all. According to Dainik Jagran, they say what was seized is "Panta Gori Beauty Cream", made by an Indian firm whose packaging gives an address in Kurukshetra district, Haryana. They have shown GST invoices, a manufacturing licence and lab reports. Officials' doubts come partly from the Urdu-script text on the packets and the look-alike name and design. None of the traders' papers has been independently checked yet, the report said, and the seized stock still has to be tested.

So which metal is it? The CDSCO alert, as ANI reported it, didn't name one. Dainik Jagran reported that the Madhya Pradesh warning mentioned mercury, which can harm the kidneys and nervous system. This isn't the first time Goree has been flagged, either. The Free Press Journal reported in September that Maharashtra's FDA had declared it not of standard quality in July after lab tests found mercury and lead above permissible limits.

Online shoppers should pay attention too. In September The Week reported that these creams had turned up on big shopping sites, sometimes listed as "Made in India", and that Amazon took down one listing.

What can you do? CDSCO's advice is to buy cosmetics that print a manufacturing licence number, the maker's details, a batch number and manufacturing and expiry dates. An imported product should also show an import registration number. If those are missing, complain to your State Drugs Controller, or to the Drugs Controller General of India for imports. In Madhya Pradesh, people can report sales to their district drug inspector.

What's next? Lab results on the Indore samples should settle two questions: whether the seized cream is the banned product, and whether it contains mercury. Until then, the safest move is to skip any whitening cream that doesn't carry these label details.

BannedGoree and Chandni creams
Seized in IndoreAbout 300 packets
Check before buyingLicence and batch number

Source ledger · स्रोत खाता

Each fact in this story, where it came from, and how it was checked.

FactSourceCheck
MP FDA on 14 Nov banned sale, purchase and use of Gori/Goree Beauty Cream and Chandni Whitening Cream, described as Pakistan-madeFree Press Journal, Dainik Jagran English (MP/CG)Confirmed, independent outlets
MP warning: heavy metals may cause toxic effects / kidney damageFree Press Journal, Dainik Jagran English (MP/CG)Confirmed, independent outlets
CDSCO public health alert in mid-September: heavy metals beyond limits; no import registration certificateANI, The NewsMill (TNM Bureau with ANI inputs)Confirmed, independent outlets
Indore raids at a Ranipura shop and Padmashree Agency, Chhawani; ~300 packets worth ~₹1.5 lakh seized at distributorFree Press JournalSingle source
315 pieces seized at the agency; three pieces sealed at Ranipura shop by three-member team led by drug inspector Varun Kumar RaiDainik Jagran English (MP/CG)Single source
Traders say product is 'Panta Gori Beauty Cream' made by Indian firm with Kurukshetra, Haryana address; showed GST invoices, licence, lab reports; papers not yet independently verified; stock to be testedDainik Jagran English (MP/CG)Single source
CDSCO alert did not name the specific metalANI, The WeekConfirmed, independent outlets
MP warning mentioned mercury; mercury can damage kidneys and nervous systemDainik Jagran English (MP/CG)Single source
Maharashtra FDA in July declared Goree Beauty Cream not of standard quality after tests found mercury and lead above limitsFree Press Journal (Mumbai)Single source
The creams were listed on major e-commerce sites, sometimes as 'Made in India'; Amazon removed a listingThe WeekSingle source
CDSCO advice: check manufacturing licence no., manufacturer details, batch no., mfg/expiry dates, import registration no.; report to State Drugs Controller or DCGIANI, The NewsMill (TNM Bureau with ANI inputs)Confirmed, independent outlets
MP residents can report sales to district drug inspectorFree Press JournalSingle source

Corrections to this story: none.